Pricing

What Companies Use Surveillance Pricing? What the Evidence Shows

No named company has been proven to set individual prices from personal data, but nine are under FTC order to explain how they price, and one faces a lawsuit.

SD Frivolous Editorial · Published Nov 18, 2026 · 12 sources

Short answer

As of November 13, 2026, no regulator or court has found that a named US company sets individual prices from personal data, which is what surveillance pricing means. The public record is narrower: FTC orders to nine companies, one pending lawsuit against JetBlue, price tests at Instacart, location pricing at Target and Staples, and written denials from Amazon, Walmart, Delta, JetBlue, Target and Uber.

Editorial illustration for Companies and the evidence
At a glance
Proven cases of individual pricing from personal dataNone found in agency findings or court rulings as of November 13, 2026
Under FTC 6(b) order (October 28, 2026)Delta, United, JetBlue, Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, Instacart, Target and Walmart; an information demand, not an accusation
Sued over surveillance pricingJetBlue, in a proposed class action filed April 22, 2026 (E.D.N.Y.); JetBlue denies the claim
Documented price testsInstacart (ended December 22, 2025); Amazon (random DVD price test, 2000)
Documented location pricingTarget app ($5 million California settlement, 2022); Staples and Princeton Review (press investigations)
Asked by Congress43 companies received letters from Rep. Frank Pallone between May and October 2026
Last updateNovember 18, 2026 (status checked November 13, 2026)

What companies use surveillance pricing? What the evidence shows

Surveillance pricing is a price set for one person, or a narrow group, from personal data about them. Measured against that definition, the honest answer is that nobody outside the companies knows. The FTC said so itself in the enforcement policy statement it proposed on August 19, 2026: the extent to which businesses use personalized pricing "is not well understood," according to the proposed statement.

The agency's first study did not close the gap. Its 2024 orders went to eight firms that sell pricing tools, and the FTC now says that study "learned nothing about actual pricing decisions" because it examined middlemen, per the FTC's October 28, 2026 release. That is why the new orders go directly to airlines, ride and delivery apps and two retailers. Our surveillance pricing explainer covers the definition and the law; this page covers the companies.

What exists today falls into four groups: companies ordered to hand over information, one company sued, companies caught running price tests or location pricing, and companies that have put denials in writing. None of those is the same as a finding that a company charges you more because of who you are.

How we source each company

Every company statement on this page is tied to one of four source types, linked in the same paragraph: an agency or congressional document, a court filing or settlement, a published study or press investigation, or the company's own statement. We separate four practices that are often run together:

  • Personalized (surveillance) pricing: a price that turns on data about the individual shopper.
  • Price testing: showing different shoppers different prices at random to measure demand.
  • Location pricing: prices that vary by store, ZIP code or where the phone is.
  • Dynamic pricing: one price for everyone that moves with demand or time.

Where we found no credible evidence of individual pricing from personal data, the entry says so. An FTC order or a congressional letter is a question, not a finding. A lawsuit is an allegation until a court rules.

Company evidence table

Status as of November 13, 2026. Sources for each row are linked in the company sections below.

CompanyPractice alleged or shownSource typeDateLegal action statusCompany response
AmazonRandom price test on 68 DVDs; no evidence found of pricing by personal dataCompany statement; congressional letter2000; May 2026None found on personalized pricingSays it does not use personal information to charge higher prices
WalmartNo evidence found; digital shelf labels raised questionsFTC 6(b) order; congressional letterOctober 28, 2026FTC information order pending"We price the product, not the person"
KrogerLoyalty data profiles used to target discounts; senators questioned digital labelsConsumer Reports investigation; Senate letter2024 to 2025None foundSays it has never engaged in surge pricing
InstacartPrice tests showed different prices for identical cartsConsumer Reports study; New York attorney general letter; FTC orderDecember 2025 to October 2026State and FTC inquiries; no enforcement action foundEnded the tests; says they never used personal data
TargetApp prices changed when the phone entered a storeCalifornia settlement; FTC order2022; October 28, 2026Settled for $5 million in 2022; FTC information order pendingSays it does not use personal information to raise prices
JetBlueAlleged use of browsing data to set faresClass action complaint; FTC orderApril 22, 2026Pending in the Eastern District of New YorkDenies using personal information or browsing history
DeltaAI fare tool drew senators' questionsSenate letter; FTC orderJuly 2025; October 28, 2026FTC information order pendingSays no fare product targets individuals using personal data
UberStudies found rising and variable take from fares; location used for feesAcademic studies; New York label; FTC order2025 to 2026FTC information order pendingSays prices are not personalised

Retailers

Does Amazon use surveillance pricing?

No evidence found that Amazon sets prices from a shopper's personal data. The episode most often cited is from September 2000, when customers noticed different DVD prices. Amazon said it had varied discounts on 68 DVD titles for five days "on a totally random basis, not with respect to customer demographic information," and refunded 6,896 customers an average of $3.10, according to Amazon's statement at the time. That was a price test, not personal pricing.

Amazon is one of 25 retailers that Rep. Frank Pallone asked on May 12, 2026 to explain their pricing, per the House Energy and Commerce Democrats' release. In October 2026 the company told NPR that it offers all customers "the same everyday low prices" and does not use personal information to charge higher prices, according to an editor's note on the broadcast. Amazon was not among the nine companies in the FTC's October 2026 orders. The FTC's separate antitrust case over Amazon's pricing algorithm concerns competition, not individual prices, the Associated Press reported.

Does Walmart use surveillance pricing?

No evidence found. Concern began when Walmart announced digital shelf labels in June 2024; a spokesperson said the program "is not designed for dynamic pricing," Retail Brew reported. In a letter dated September 25, 2026, Walmart's chief executive wrote, "We price the product, not the person," and said the company does not set different prices based on who a customer is or the time of day, per Walmart's published letter.

Walmart received one of the FTC's October 28, 2026 orders and must answer within 45 days of receipt. It had not commented on the order when Retail Dive reported on it the next day.

Kroger surveillance pricing

No evidence found that Kroger sets shelf prices by shopper. Two things are documented. In August 2024, Senators Elizabeth Warren and Bob Casey wrote to Kroger about electronic shelf labels and the potential to build personalized profiles of customers; Kroger answered that it "does not and has never engaged in 'surge pricing,'" according to The Record.

Then, in May 2025, a Consumer Reports investigation found that Kroger builds detailed profiles of loyalty program members and uses them to target offers, so that a shopper judged to have a lower income "could end up getting fewer of Kroger's best discounts," per Consumer Reports. That is personalized discounting, which changes what a shopper pays without changing the shelf price. Kroger is on the list of retailers that received the May 2026 congressional letter.

Target and Instacart

Target has the only completed enforcement action on this page, and it concerned location, not personal profiles. In March 2022, Target agreed to pay $5 million in civil penalties to settle a complaint by seven California district attorneys that its app advertised different prices once a customer entered a store's perimeter; the judgment bars app price changes based on the user's location, City News Service reported. Target's October 2026 pricing fact sheet states that it "does not use personal information to raise prices for guests based on who they are, where they live or when they shop." Target also received an October 2026 FTC order.

Instacart ran price tests that showed different shoppers different prices for the same items at the same store. After a December 2025 study by Consumer Reports and partners, Instacart announced on December 22, 2025 that it was "ending all item price tests" and said the tests "were never based on supply or demand, personal data, demographics, or individual shopping behavior," per Instacart's statement. New York Attorney General Letitia James sent the company a letter on January 8, 2026 demanding information about its algorithmic pricing, according to her office. We found no enforcement action over the tests as of November 13, 2026.

Travel and rides

JetBlue surveillance pricing

JetBlue is the one company on this page facing a lawsuit that uses the term. Phillips v. JetBlue Airways Corp., No. 1:26-cv-02405 (E.D.N.Y.), filed April 22, 2026, alleges that JetBlue tracked a customer's browsing while he booked and used the data to set fares, in violation of the federal Electronic Communications Privacy Act and two New York consumer statutes. The complaint itself concedes that surveillance pricing is not illegal in the United States; its theory is collection without consent, according to Mayer Brown's summary of the case.

The suit leans on a since-deleted reply from JetBlue's social media account telling a customer who complained about a $230 fare jump to clear cookies or use an incognito window. JetBlue told CBS News the reply was "simply a mistake" by one crewmember and that it "does not use personal information or web browsing history to set individual pricing," per CBS News. The public docket shows a June 2026 motion to consolidate related cases; we found no ruling on the merits as of November 13, 2026 (docket). JetBlue also received an FTC order in October 2026.

Delta

Delta drew attention in July 2025 over its use of AI in fare setting, and senators wrote to ask whether fares would be individualized. Delta's written reply, dated July 31, 2025, said: "There is no fare product Delta has ever used, is testing or plans to use that targets customers with individualized prices based on personal data," and that it shares no personal information with its pricing vendor, per Delta's published letter. Delta and United are among the airlines under the October 2026 FTC orders, and eight airlines received congressional letters in August 2026 (House Energy and Commerce Democrats).

Uber surveillance pricing

No evidence found that Uber prices rides from a rider's personal traits. Two 2025 academic studies, one from Columbia using 24,532 trips by a single US driver and one from Oxford using 1.5 million UK trips, found that the share of each fare Uber keeps rose after it moved to upfront pricing. Both measured the split between rider fare and driver pay, not prices tied to an individual's data. Uber's response was that upfront prices "are not personalised" and that its algorithms do not use a rider's or driver's personal characteristics, as reported by The Guardian.

Uber and DoorDash did begin showing New York's algorithmic pricing notice in November 2025. Uber's notice said location is used to calculate fees and savings, and DoorDash said it uses information such as the delivery address to calculate distance and fees, Business Insider reported. The FTC's October 2026 orders to Uber, Lyft, DoorDash and Instacart also ask how personal data affects what drivers and couriers are paid.

What stores use surveillance pricing: how to tell

A shopper cannot see how a price was set, so the practical signals are indirect.

  • The New York label. In New York, a price set by an algorithm using personal data must carry a disclosure. A label tells you personal data, which can be as simple as a delivery address, fed the price. It does not tell you the price is higher for you.
  • Same item, same moment, different price. Compare logged in and logged out, or on two accounts. A gap can come from a test, a location rule or a targeted coupon as easily as from profiling.
  • App price versus shelf price. The Target settlement turned on app prices changing inside the store.
  • Loyalty offers. Targeted coupons are the most common documented form of individual pricing, as the Kroger investigation showed.
  • Who has been asked. Congressional letters have gone to 43 companies in three rounds, the latest on October 22, 2026 to ride, ticketing, travel and delivery firms, per the House Energy and Commerce Democrats.

Older press investigations show what location pricing looks like in practice. ProPublica found in 2015 that The Princeton Review's online tutoring price varied by ZIP code from $6,600 to $8,400, and noted earlier reporting that Staples appeared to set online prices by a user's distance from a rival store (ProPublica). Wendy's, often named in this debate, said in February 2024 that it had "no plans" to raise prices at busy times (Wendy's). State rules that now limit these practices are covered in our guide to algorithmic pricing laws.

Bottom line

No named company has been found by a regulator or court to set individual prices from personal data as of November 13, 2026. Nine companies, including Walmart, Target, Uber, Delta and JetBlue, are under FTC order to explain their pricing, and JetBlue faces a pending class action it denies. Documented conduct so far is price testing at Instacart, location pricing at Target and targeted discounts at Kroger.

Which Companies Use Surveillance Pricing?: key factsPRICING . KEY FACTSCompanies and the evidencePROVEN CASES OF INDIVIDUAL PRICING FROM PERSONAL DATANone found in agency findings or court rulings as of November 13, 2026UNDER FTC 6(B) ORDER (OCTOBER 28, 2026)Delta, United, JetBlue, Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, Instacart, Target and...SUED OVER SURVEILLANCE PRICINGJetBlue, in a proposed class action filed April 22, 2026 (E.D.N.Y.);...DOCUMENTED PRICE TESTSInstacart (ended December 22, 2025); Amazon (random DVD price test,...SD FRIVOLOUS . AS OF NOV 18, 2026
Key facts at a glance. Sources listed below.

What changed

  • 2026-11-18: Page published with company status checked on November 13, 2026.
  • 2026-10-28: FTC issued 6(b) orders to Delta, United, JetBlue, Lyft, Uber, DoorDash, Instacart, Target and Walmart.
  • 2026-10-22: Rep. Pallone sent a third round of letters, to ten ride, ticketing, travel and delivery companies.
  • 2026-04-22: Phillips v. JetBlue Airways Corp. filed in the Eastern District of New York.
  • 2026-01-08: New York's attorney general sent Instacart a letter demanding information on its price tests.
  • 2025-12-22: Instacart announced the end of all item price tests.

Frequently asked questions

Does Amazon use surveillance pricing?

No evidence found as of November 13, 2026. Amazon ran a random DVD price test in 2000 and refunded customers, and it told NPR in October 2026 that it does not use personal information to charge higher prices. It received a congressional letter in May 2026 but was not among the nine companies under FTC order.

Does Walmart use surveillance pricing?

No evidence found. Walmart's chief executive wrote in September 2026 that the company prices the product, not the person. Walmart is one of nine companies the FTC ordered on October 28, 2026 to explain how it sets prices, which is an information demand and not an accusation.

What stores use surveillance pricing?

No store has been found by a regulator or court to set individual prices from personal data. Documented practices are narrower: Instacart price tests that ended in December 2025, Target app prices that changed inside stores, and Kroger discounts targeted from loyalty profiles.

Who uses surveillance pricing?

The FTC says the extent of personalized pricing is not well understood. Its 2024 study found pricing vendors with at least 250 retail clients, and its October 2026 orders ask nine airlines, ride and delivery apps and retailers directly. Answers are due 45 days after each company receives its order.

Is JetBlue being sued for surveillance pricing?

Yes. Phillips v. JetBlue Airways Corp. was filed on April 22, 2026 in federal court in Brooklyn and alleges JetBlue used browsing data to set fares without consent. JetBlue denies using personal information or browsing history for pricing. No merits ruling was found as of November 13, 2026.

Sources

  1. FTC: Launches personalized pricing and compensation inquiry (Oct. 28, 2026)
  2. FTC: Proposed enforcement policy statement on personalized pricing (Aug. 19, 2026)
  3. House Energy and Commerce Democrats: Pallone launches surveillance pricing inquiry (May 2026)
  4. House Energy and Commerce Democrats: Pallone continues inquiry (Oct. 22, 2026)
  5. New York Attorney General: James demands answers from Instacart (Jan. 8, 2026)
  6. Docket: Phillips v. JetBlue Airways Corp., No. 1:26-cv-02405 (E.D.N.Y.)
  7. Mayer Brown: New class action targets surveillance pricing (May 2026)
  8. CBS News: JetBlue used customers' personal data to set ticket prices, lawsuit alleges
  9. Amazon: Statement regarding random price testing (Sept. 2000)
  10. Walmart: Letter from our CEO (Sept. 25, 2026)
  11. Delta: Response on AI pricing (letter dated July 31, 2025)
  12. Consumer Reports: Kroger loyalty program data investigation (May 21, 2025)
Legal disclaimer

This page is journalism and commentary, not legal advice. AI law changes quickly; check the primary sources above and consult qualified counsel for your situation.

Keep reading

Related coverage