Federal preemption

Can Congress Block State AI Laws? The AI Moratorium Fight Explained

Congress has the power to override state AI laws but has twice declined to use it, leaving an executive order, one lawsuit and pending bills.

SD Frivolous Editorial · Published Nov 18, 2026 · 12 sources

Short answer

Congress can preempt state AI laws by statute, but as of November 13, 2026 it has not. The Senate voted 99 to 1 on July 1, 2025 to strip a 10 year AI moratorium from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and a second attempt was left out of the fiscal 2026 defense bill in December 2025. State AI laws remain in force.

Editorial illustration for Federal preemption
At a glance
Federal statute preempting state AI lawsNone enacted as of November 13, 2026
Budget bill moratorium10 year pause in House-passed H.R. 1; struck by the Senate 99 to 1 on July 1, 2025
Defense bill attemptLeft out of the fiscal 2026 NDAA, confirmed by House leadership in early December 2025
Executive actionExecutive Order 14365 (December 11, 2025): AI Litigation Task Force, funding conditions, agency preemption theories
Litigation so farOne Justice Department intervention, against Colorado's AI Act (April 24, 2026)
White House request to CongressLegislative recommendations of March 20, 2026 ask Congress to preempt state laws that impose undue burdens
Pending vehiclesH.R. 5388 (5 year moratorium), the FRONTIER Act (frontier AI only), a Great American AI Act discussion draft
Last updateNovember 18, 2026 (status checked November 13, 2026)

Can the federal government stop states from regulating AI?

Congress can. The executive branch, acting alone, mostly cannot. Under the Supremacy Clause, federal law is "the supreme Law of the Land," and a federal statute preempts state law when it says so expressly or when the two conflict, as the Congressional Research Service explains in its legal primer on federal preemption (R45825). An AI moratorium is express preemption in its bluntest form: a statute telling states they may not enforce a category of their own laws for a set number of years.

An executive order is different. It directs federal agencies and has no preemptive force of its own, because it is neither a statute nor a regulation, as Ropes & Gray's March 2026 analysis puts it. An order can only work through lawsuits, agency rules and conditions on federal money, and a court can reject each of those. That is why the fight over federal AI preemption keeps returning to Congress, and why every state law on our state AI law tracker is still enforceable today.

AttemptVehicleDateOutcomeVoteSource
10 year moratoriumH.R. 1, One Big Beautiful Bill Act, sec. 43201 (House text)May 22, 2025Passed the House inside the budget bill215 to 214House Roll Call 145
Strike the moratoriumBlackburn Amendment No. 2814 to H.R. 1July 1, 2025Moratorium removed99 to 1Senate Vote 363
5 year moratorium billH.R. 5388, American Artificial Intelligence Leadership and Uniformity ActSeptember 16, 2025Introduced and referred to committeeNoneBill text
Defense bill riderFiscal 2026 NDAAEarly December 2025Left out of the billNoneFisher Phillips
Executive orderExecutive Order 14365December 11, 2025In effect; directs litigation and agency actionNot applicable90 Fed. Reg. 58499
White House frameworkLegislative recommendations to CongressMarch 20, 2026No bill enactedNoneWhite House
Frontier AI preemptionGreat American AI Act draft; FRONTIER ActJune 4 and July 2026Draft released; bill introduced; no voteNoneRep. Trahan

The 10 year moratorium on AI in the Big Beautiful Bill

What it would have done

The House version of H.R. 1, the budget reconciliation bill known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, included section 43201, titled "Artificial intelligence and information technology" (engrossed House text). For 10 years it would have barred states from enforcing laws or regulations that limit, restrict or regulate AI models, AI systems or automated decision systems, as summarized by the Future of Privacy Forum. The House passed the bill on May 22, 2025 by 215 to 214 (Roll Call 145).

The Senate had a procedural problem. Under the Byrd rule, section 313 of the Congressional Budget Act, provisions that are extraneous to the budget can be struck from a reconciliation bill unless three fifths of senators vote to waive the rule (CRS report RL30862). Senator Ted Cruz recast the ban as a funding condition: states would have to pause AI enforcement to remain eligible for certain Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) money. The Senate parliamentarian concluded that version complied with the Byrd rule, according to Covington's account.

The 2025 Senate vote that stripped it

Opposition from governors, state attorneys general and senators in both parties grew through June 2025. A compromise between Cruz and Senator Marsha Blackburn would have cut the pause from 10 years to 5, but the deal collapsed, per Covington. Blackburn then offered Amendment No. 2814 to strike the section. It passed 99 to 1 at 4:08 a.m. on July 1, 2025, with Senator Thom Tillis the only no vote (Senate Vote 363).

The bill became Public Law 119-21 on July 4, 2025 (govinfo), enacted without any AI preemption or moratorium provision, as Covington later noted. So the answer to the common question about AI regulation in the Big Beautiful Bill is that the final law contains none.

The AI moratorium NDAA attempt

Supporters tried again in late 2025 by seeking to attach a federal standard to the National Defense Authorization Act for fiscal 2026, a bill Congress passes every year. President Trump publicly urged Congress to use the NDAA, and White House AI adviser David Sacks led a late push, according to Fisher Phillips. In early December 2025, House Majority Leader Steve Scalise confirmed the AI moratorium was out of the defense bill and said the NDAA was not the best place for it.

That was the second failure in six months, and it sent the effort to the executive branch. We found no reported attempt to add state AI preemption to the fiscal 2027 NDAA as of November 13, 2026.

The December 2025 order and the AI Litigation Task Force

Executive Order 14365, "Ensuring a National Policy Framework for Artificial Intelligence," was signed on December 11, 2025 and published at 90 Fed. Reg. 58499. It does not preempt anything by its own terms. It sets five tracks in motion:

  • Litigation (sec. 3): the Attorney General must create an AI Litigation Task Force within 30 days to challenge state AI laws.
  • A list (sec. 4): the Commerce Secretary must publish, within 90 days, an evaluation that identifies "onerous" state AI laws.
  • Funding (sec. 5): states with such laws become ineligible for BEAD non-deployment funds "to the maximum extent allowed by Federal law," and agencies must look at conditioning other grants.
  • Agencies (secs. 6 and 7): the FCC is to open a proceeding on a federal reporting and disclosure standard, and the FTC is to issue a policy statement on when state laws that require changes to truthful AI outputs are preempted.
  • Legislation (sec. 8): the administration is to prepare a preemption proposal for Congress that leaves alone state child safety protections, data center infrastructure rules and state government procurement and use of AI.

The Justice Department created the task force by memorandum on January 9, 2026. The only state law the order names is Colorado's, and Colorado is where the first case came. On April 24, 2026 the department moved to intervene in X.AI, LLC v. Weiser, No. 1:26-cv-01515 (D. Colo.), arguing that the Colorado AI Act violates the Equal Protection Clause. That is a constitutional claim, not a preemption claim. Enforcement was stayed by agreement on April 27, 2026, and Colorado's legislature then passed SB 26-189 to repeal and replace the law, with duties starting January 1, 2027, per Proskauer. No court has ruled that federal law preempts a state AI law. Our Colorado page tracks the replacement statute.

The other tracks have moved slowly. The FTC proposed its policy statement on July 1, 2026 and took comments until July 31, per the FTC's release. Commerce had not publicly released its list of state laws when Jenner & Block reviewed the order's deadlines in late April 2026, and we have not found a published list since. We found no Justice Department suit against California or any other state as of November 13, 2026.

The March 2026 White House framework asking Congress to preempt

On March 20, 2026 the White House sent Congress its National Policy Framework for Artificial Intelligence: Legislative Recommendations. Section VII says Congress "should preempt state AI laws that impose undue burdens." It asks for three limits on states: they should not regulate AI development, should not unduly burden uses of AI that would be lawful without AI, and should not penalize developers for a third party's unlawful conduct.

The framework also says what states would keep: traditional police powers and laws of general applicability that protect children, prevent fraud and protect consumers; zoning authority; and control over a state's own use of AI. It adds that Congress should not create a new federal rulemaking body for AI. The request is narrower than the 2025 moratorium, which paused nearly all AI-specific state law, but it is a request. Nothing in it binds a state until Congress enacts it.

Three legislative vehicles exist. H.R. 5388, introduced by Rep. Michael Baumgartner on September 16, 2025, would impose a 5 year moratorium with exceptions for generally applicable laws, criminal penalties and state procurement (bill text). On June 4, 2026, Reps. Jay Obernolte and Lori Trahan released a discussion draft, the Great American AI Act, that would preempt state laws specifically regulating AI model development for three years, per Covington. In July 2026 Trahan and cosponsors introduced the narrower FRONTIER Act, which would bar new state obligations on frontier AI developers in three areas (catastrophic-risk transparency, third-party auditing and incident reporting) while preserving generally applicable laws, laws protecting minors and state procurement, according to Rep. Trahan's office. None has received a floor vote.

What AI preemption would mean for state laws

The effect depends on the text that passes. A broad moratorium like the 2025 House version would have suspended enforcement of most AI-specific state statutes at once. The FRONTIER Act model is targeted: its sponsors' summary names California SB 53, New York's RAISE Act and Illinois SB 315 as the kind of frontier developer laws it would displace (section-by-section summary). Laws on chatbots and minors, deepfakes, hiring and consumer protection would mostly survive under either the White House framework or the FRONTIER Act, because both preserve child safety and generally applicable laws. See our pages on California SB 53 and the federal bill tracker.

The political odds moved in November 2026. Democrats won both chambers in the November 3 midterm elections and will control Congress from January, which makes broad preemption considerably less likely, in the assessment of Jones Walker's post-election analysis. The current Congress returned on November 9 for a lame duck session. One lobbying firm's outlook lists a children's online safety package that could carry preemption of certain state AI laws, and rates it unlikely to pass (BGR Group).

For anyone subject to state AI laws, the working assumption has not changed since July 2025: comply with the state law in front of you. The executive order route has produced one intervention and one proposed agency statement in eleven months, and no ruling that displaces a state statute. Companies building compliance programs around these laws can start with our AI governance guide.

Bottom line

Congress has the constitutional power to block state AI laws and has twice declined to use it: the Senate struck the 10 year moratorium 99 to 1 on July 1, 2025, and the fiscal 2026 defense bill left it out. Executive Order 14365 has produced one Justice Department intervention and no preemption ruling. As of November 13, 2026, state AI laws remain enforceable.

Can Congress Block State AI Laws?: key factsFEDERAL PREEMPTION . KEY FACTSFederal preemptionFEDERAL STATUTE PREEMPTING STATE AI LAWSNone enacted as of November 13, 2026BUDGET BILL MORATORIUM10 year pause in House-passed H.R. 1; struck by the Senate 99 to 1...DEFENSE BILL ATTEMPTLeft out of the fiscal 2026 NDAA, confirmed by House leadership in...EXECUTIVE ACTIONExecutive Order 14365 (December 11, 2025): AI Litigation Task Force,...SD FRIVOLOUS . AS OF NOV 18, 2026
Key facts at a glance. Sources listed below.

What changed

  • 2026-11-18: Page published with status checked on November 13, 2026.
  • 2026-07-01: FTC proposed a policy statement on preemption of state laws affecting AI outputs, as directed by Executive Order 14365.
  • 2026-06-04: Great American AI Act discussion draft released with a three year preemption of state AI development laws.
  • 2026-04-24: Justice Department moved to intervene in X.AI, LLC v. Weiser against Colorado's AI Act.
  • 2026-03-20: White House sent Congress legislative recommendations asking it to preempt unduly burdensome state AI laws.
  • 2026-01-09: Justice Department created the AI Litigation Task Force.
  • 2025-12-11: Executive Order 14365 signed.
  • 2025-07-01: Senate voted 99 to 1 to strike the AI moratorium from H.R. 1.
  • 2025-05-22: House passed H.R. 1 with a 10 year moratorium on state AI law enforcement.

Frequently asked questions

What was the AI moratorium in the Big Beautiful Bill?

It was section 43201 of the House-passed One Big Beautiful Bill Act, H.R. 1. It would have barred states for 10 years from enforcing laws that limit, restrict or regulate AI models, AI systems or automated decision systems. The Senate removed it before the bill became law on July 4, 2025.

Did the AI regulation ban pass?

No. The Senate voted 99 to 1 on July 1, 2025 to strike the moratorium from the budget bill, and a second attempt was left out of the fiscal 2026 defense bill in December 2025. As of November 13, 2026, no federal law blocks states from regulating AI.

Can Congress preempt state AI laws?

Yes. Under the Supremacy Clause, a federal statute can expressly override state law, and AI is within Congress's power over interstate commerce. What Congress has lacked is the votes. An executive order cannot preempt state law without a statute, a valid regulation or a court ruling behind it.

Is there still an AI moratorium bill?

Yes, though none has advanced to a vote. H.R. 5388 proposes a 5 year moratorium, and the FRONTIER Act, introduced in July 2026, would preempt new state rules for frontier AI developers only. The White House asked Congress on March 20, 2026 to pass preemption legislation.

What does Executive Order 14365 do to state AI laws?

Nothing directly. It created a Justice Department task force to challenge state AI laws in court, told Commerce to list onerous state laws, tied some broadband funding to that list and asked the FCC and FTC to develop preemption positions. State laws stay in force unless a court or Congress says otherwise.

Sources

  1. Senate Roll Call Vote 363, Blackburn Amdt. No. 2814 (July 1, 2025)
  2. House Clerk: Roll Call 145, H.R. 1 (May 22, 2025)
  3. govinfo: H.R. 1, engrossed in House (sec. 43201)
  4. govinfo: Public Law 119-21 (approved July 4, 2025)
  5. Federal Register: Executive Order 14365, 90 Fed. Reg. 58499 (Dec. 16, 2025)
  6. White House: National Policy Framework for AI, Legislative Recommendations (March 20, 2026)
  7. Justice Department: AI Litigation Task Force memorandum (Jan. 9, 2026)
  8. Justice Department: Intervention in xAI lawsuit against Colorado (April 24, 2026)
  9. FTC: Seeks comment on policy statement addressing AI accuracy (July 1, 2026)
  10. govinfo: H.R. 5388, American Artificial Intelligence Leadership and Uniformity Act
  11. Covington: Senate nixes state AI enforcement moratorium, for now (July 8, 2025)
  12. Jones Walker: AI after the midterms (Nov. 6, 2026)
Legal disclaimer

This page is journalism and commentary, not legal advice. AI law changes quickly; check the primary sources above and consult qualified counsel for your situation.

Keep reading

Related coverage