Status at a glance
Three different measures share the name App Store Accountability Act. One is a pair of bills in Congress. The other two are state laws in Utah and Texas, and they are at very different stages. The table gives the position as of November 14, 2026.
| Version | Bill number | Status | Duties start | Enforced by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Federal | H.R. 3149 and S. 1586, 119th Congress | Pending. Reported by House committee as amended, 26 to 23; no floor vote found | One year after enactment, if enacted | FTC and state attorneys general |
| Texas | SB 2420 (2025), Business and Commerce Code chapter 121 | Enforceable while the Fifth Circuit appeal is pending | January 1, 2026 on paper; enforceable in practice from the Fifth Circuit stays of late May and June 4, 2026 | Deceptive Trade Practices Act |
| Utah | SB 142 (2025), amended by HB 498 (2026), Utah Code chapter 13-76 | Enacted; main duties not yet in force | May 6, 2027 | Private lawsuits only |
The federal bill has moved further than most children's online safety bills this Congress, but it has not reached the House floor. The official bill status record for H.R. 3149 shows introduction on May 1, 2025 and a voice vote in the Commerce, Manufacturing, and Trade Subcommittee on December 11, 2025 forwarding an amended bill to the full committee. The Energy and Commerce Committee's markup recap records that the full committee reported it to the House, as amended, by 26 yeas to 23 nays on March 5, 2026.
The Senate companion has not moved. The status record for S. 1586 lists one action: referral to the Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee on the day it was introduced. We found no record of a floor vote on either bill as of November 14, 2026.
What would the federal App Store Accountability Act require?
This section describes the introduced text of H.R. 3149, which the Congressional Research Service identifies as identical to S. 1586. The committee amended the House bill before reporting it, so the version that reaches the floor may differ.
Who is covered
The bill applies to a "covered app store provider": any person that owns or controls an app store available in the United States with more than 5,000,000 U.S. users. It also applies to app developers whose apps are offered through those stores. A minor is anyone under 18.
App store duties
- Verify age at sign-up. When someone creates an account, the store must ask for age information and verify the person's age category using a commercially available method reasonably designed to ensure accuracy. The categories are young child (under 13), child (13 to 15), teenager (16 to 17) and adult.
- Link minors to a parent. A minor's account must be affiliated with a parental account.
- Get parental consent. The store must obtain verifiable parental consent before a minor downloads an app, buys an app or makes an in-app purchase, and again after a developer reports a significant change.
- Share a signal with developers. The store must give developers each user's age category and, for minors, whether consent was obtained, in real time, and must tell them when a parent revokes consent.
- Limit data use. Age verification data may be collected and kept only as strictly necessary, and must be protected with safeguards that include industry-standard encryption.
Developer duties
Developers would have to check age category and consent through the store's system, notify the store of significant changes, and use the store's signal to determine a user's age category. Receipt of that signal counts as actual knowledge of the user's age category. A developer could not enforce a contract or terms of service against a minor without verified parental consent, and could not share age category data with unaffiliated third parties.
Enforcement, safe harbor and preemption
A violation would be treated as an unfair or deceptive practice under the Federal Trade Commission Act. State attorneys general could also sue in federal court for injunctions, damages and restitution. The bill contains no private right of action. Developers that rely in good faith on a store's age data and follow accepted industry standards for age ratings would have a safe harbor.
Section 9 would bar any state or locality from maintaining or enforcing a law "related to the provisions" of the Act, while leaving contract and tort law untouched. That clause is the main practical difference for Utah and Texas: if the introduced text became law, their statutes would be exposed to a preemption challenge. The Act would take effect one year after enactment.
Is it part of the KIDS Act?
No. The House passed the KIDS Act, H.R. 7757, in June 2026, but the engrossed text of that package has titles on obscenity, online platforms, social gaming, AI chatbots, research and children's privacy, and no app store title. H.R. 3149 was reported separately at the same March 5, 2026 markup. Our page on the Kids Online Safety Act covers the package.
What does the Utah App Store Accountability Act require?
Utah passed the first law of this kind in 2025: SB 142, enacted as Laws of Utah 2025, chapter 446, and codified as Utah Code chapter 13-76. As first enacted, the store and developer duties were due to start May 6, 2026 and parents were to gain a right to sue on December 31, 2026.
Neither date held. Governor Spencer Cox signed HB 498, the Utah App Store Accountability Act Amendments, on March 18, 2026. The enrolled text of HB 498 rewrites the core sections so that each duty applies "beginning May 6, 2027".
Duties from May 6, 2027
- Age verification. App store providers must request and verify the age category of anyone in Utah who creates an account. For accounts that already exist, they have 12 months after the duties take effect. For a minor, verification must include an affirmative age attestation by a parent.
- Parental consent. A minor's account must be affiliated with a parent account, and the store must get verifiable parental consent before the minor downloads an app, buys an app or makes an in-app purchase.
- Pre-installed apps. HB 498 adds browsers, search engines and messaging apps that ship on a device. Developers must request age category data or parental consent when an account holder first launches one.
- Developer limits. Developers may use age category data only for age restrictions, legal compliance and safety features, must apply the lowest indicated age category when first setting safety defaults, and may ask a store to block minor accounts from their app.
Enforcement
HB 498 removed the clause that treated violations as deceptive trade practices and repealed the Division of Consumer Protection's rulemaking section. What remains is a private claim. From May 6, 2027, a minor who has been harmed, or that minor's parent, may sue an app store provider or developer, and the court must award the greater of actual damages or $1,000 per violation, plus attorney fees and costs, under the amended section 13-76-401.
Is the Texas App Store Accountability Act in effect?
Yes, as of November 14, 2026, while a federal appeal continues. The Texas Legislature passed SB 2420 by 30 to 1 in the Senate and 120 to 9 in the House, according to the certification on the enrolled bill, and Governor Greg Abbott signed it on May 27, 2025, according to the Texas Attorney General. It adds chapter 121 to the Business and Commerce Code and states an effective date of January 1, 2026.
What SB 2420 requires
- Age verification. When a person in Texas creates an app store account, the store must use a commercially reasonable method to verify whether the person is a child (under 13), younger teenager (13 to 15), older teenager (16 to 17) or adult.
- Consent for every download. A minor's account must be tied to a verified parent account. The store must get consent for each individual download or purchase, and obtaining blanket consent for multiple downloads is itself a violation.
- Disclosure before consent. The parent must be shown the app's age rating, the content that led to the rating, and how the app collects, uses or shares personal data.
- Mandatory age ratings. Developers must assign an age rating to each app and each in-app purchase and give stores the reasons for it. The federal bill has no equivalent duty.
- Exceptions. No consent is needed for certain emergency services apps or for apps run by nonprofits that administer standardized college admission or placement tests.
Section 121.101 makes a violation a deceptive trade practice actionable under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, and section 121.102 says the chapter's remedies add to any others available by law. Texas also has a separate AI statute; see our page on TRAIGA and other Texas AI laws.
Federal vs state versions compared
All three versions rest on the same idea: verify age once at the app store, then pass a signal to every app. They differ in who is covered, how often parents must consent and who can enforce.
| Feature | Federal bill (as introduced) | Utah (as amended 2026) | Texas |
|---|---|---|---|
| Covered stores | Stores with more than 5,000,000 U.S. users | Any app store that lets users in Utah download apps to a mobile device | Any app store distributing apps to mobile device users in Texas |
| Parental consent | Before a minor's download, purchase or in-app purchase | Before a minor's download, purchase or in-app purchase | For each individual download or purchase; blanket consent prohibited |
| Pre-installed apps | Not addressed | Covered, including browsers, search engines and messaging apps | Not addressed |
| Developer age ratings | Not required; any rating offered must be in plain language | No duty to create a rating system | Required for every app and in-app purchase |
| Private lawsuits | None | Yes: greater of actual damages or $1,000 per violation | Through the Deceptive Trade Practices Act |
| Government enforcement | FTC and state attorneys general | Removed by HB 498 | Through the Deceptive Trade Practices Act |
| Effect on other laws | Would preempt related state laws | Leaves other remedies in place | Remedies are cumulative |
Sources for the table: the introduced H.R. 3149, the enrolled Utah HB 498 and the enrolled Texas SB 2420.
Two more states have enacted laws on the same model. Louisiana replaced its 2025 act with HB 977, Act 185 of 2026, whose main provisions take effect July 1, 2027 and which the attorney general enforces with civil fines of up to $10,000 per violation, according to the Louisiana Legislature's digest. Alabama's governor signed HB 161 as Act 2026-59 in February 2026, the Alabama Reporter reported. Our California AI law page covers that state's separate measures.
Court challenges and injunctions
Texas: blocked, then revived
Two suits challenged SB 2420 in federal court in Austin on First Amendment grounds: one by Students Engaged in Advancing Texas and two minors, and one by the Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA). CCIA says Judge Robert Pitman granted a preliminary injunction on December 23, 2025, days before the law's effective date.
Texas appealed. On June 4, 2026, a Fifth Circuit panel of Judges Smith, Haynes and Oldham granted a stay of the injunctions pending appeal in a published order in Nos. 25-51073 and 26-50001, replacing an earlier administrative stay. The panel said Texas had made a strong showing that the law at most regulates commercial speech, that it likely survives intermediate scrutiny, and that the district court's universal injunctions likely exceeded its authority. Judge Haynes concurred only in the sentence granting the stay.
Both sets of challengers asked the Supreme Court to lift the stay. The Court denied the applications on July 6, 2026, as its dockets for No. 25A1389 and No. 25A1390 show. That order did not decide whether SB 2420 is constitutional. A Texas Data Law tracker records Fifth Circuit argument on August 4, 2026 and no merits opinion in its sources as of October 13, 2026. We found no merits ruling as of November 14, 2026.
Utah: suit dropped after the amendment
CCIA sued Utah's attorney general over SB 142 in February 2026. It says it voluntarily dismissed the case in April 2026 after the legislature amended the statute to eliminate enforcement by state agencies. No court has ruled on the Utah law's constitutionality, and no injunction applies to it.
What the litigation means for the federal bill
The Fifth Circuit's stay order is the only appellate writing on this model so far, and it is preliminary. A merits decision either way would bear on the federal bill, which uses the same structure of age verification, account linking and parental consent. Related federal proposals take other routes: the GUARD Act would put age verification on AI companion providers themselves, a debate driven in part by the Character.AI lawsuits. Our federal AI bill tracker follows each of them.
App store age checks are law in Texas and scheduled in Utah, but not nationally. Texas SB 2420 is enforceable while the Fifth Circuit weighs a First Amendment appeal, and Utah's duties begin May 6, 2027 with private lawsuits as the only remedy. The federal bill, H.R. 3149, cleared a House committee 26 to 23 on March 5, 2026 and has not had a floor vote. As introduced, it would preempt related state laws.
What changed
- 2026-07-06: Supreme Court denies applications to vacate the Fifth Circuit stay (Nos. 25A1389 and 25A1390).
- 2026-06-04: Fifth Circuit stays the Texas injunctions pending appeal; SB 2420 becomes enforceable.
- 2026-03-18: Utah governor signs HB 498, moving store and developer duties to May 6, 2027 and leaving only private enforcement.
- 2026-03-05: House Energy and Commerce Committee votes 26 to 23 to report H.R. 3149 as amended.
- 2025-12-23: Federal district court in Austin preliminarily enjoins Texas SB 2420, according to CCIA.
- 2025-12-11: House subcommittee forwards H.R. 3149, amended, to the full committee by voice vote.
- 2025-05-27: Texas governor signs SB 2420.
- 2025-05-01: H.R. 3149 and S. 1586 introduced in Congress.
Frequently asked questions
What is the App Store Accountability Act?
It is the name of a federal bill (H.R. 3149 and S. 1586) and of state laws in Utah and Texas. Each makes app stores verify users' age categories, link minors' accounts to a parent, get parental consent before a minor downloads or buys an app, and pass age and consent signals to app developers.
Is the Texas App Store Accountability Act in effect?
Yes, as of November 14, 2026. A federal judge blocked SB 2420 in December 2025, but the Fifth Circuit stayed that order on June 4, 2026 and the Supreme Court declined to lift the stay on July 6, 2026. The appeal has not been decided, so the law's long-term fate is open.
What does the Utah App Store Accountability Act require?
From May 6, 2027, app stores must verify the age category of Utah account holders, tie minors' accounts to a parent account and get verifiable parental consent before downloads and purchases. Developers must check that signal, including for pre-installed apps. Only a harmed minor or parent can sue, for at least $1,000 per violation.
Has the federal App Store Accountability Act passed?
No. The House Energy and Commerce Committee voted 26 to 23 on March 5, 2026 to report H.R. 3149 as amended, but we found no House floor vote as of November 14, 2026. The Senate bill, S. 1586, has not advanced beyond referral to the Commerce Committee.
Would the federal bill override the Utah and Texas laws?
As introduced, yes in large part. Section 9 of H.R. 3149 would bar states from enforcing laws related to the Act's provisions, while preserving contract and tort law. The committee amended the bill before reporting it, so the final preemption language could differ.
Sources
- H.R. 3149, App Store Accountability Act, introduced text (GovInfo)
- H.R. 3149 bill status record (GovInfo)
- S. 1586 bill status record (GovInfo)
- House Energy and Commerce Committee: full committee markup recap (March 5, 2026)
- Texas SB 2420, enrolled text (Texas Legislature Online)
- Utah HB 498 (2026), enrolled text (Utah Legislature)
- Utah Governor: Gov. Cox signs 72 bills (March 18, 2026)
- Students Engaged in Advancing Texas v. Paxton, No. 25-51073, order of June 4, 2026 (5th Cir.)
- Supreme Court docket, No. 25A1389
- Supreme Court docket, No. 25A1390
- CCIA: CCIA v. Paxton (W.D. Tex.) litigation page
- CCIA: CCIA v. Brown litigation page
This page is journalism and commentary, not legal advice. AI law changes quickly; check the primary sources above and consult qualified counsel for your situation.
